Menu

  1. Home
  2. Menu

Introducing Betty Bakery: A charming spot in Brooklyn offering a wide array of desserts, coffee, and savory pies. Located at 448 Atlantic Ave, Betty Bakery provides delivery, takeout, gluten-free options, and more. Customer reviews rave about the attentive service and delicious treats like the carrot cake, coconut cake, and chocolate cake. The cozy atmosphere and passionate staff create a warm and inviting experience. Betty Bakery is known for their decadent baked goods, savory pies, and unique cupcakes with perfectly balanced frosting. Whether you're a sweet or savory lover, this bakery has something to satisfy every palate. Don't miss out on the cumin lamb pie or the flaky crusts that customers can't get enough of. Betty Bakery is a must-visit for those looking for a delightful culinary experience in Brooklyn.

Cakes Savory Pies Cookies Retro Items Sweet Pies Bars and Pops Tarts Cupcakes Beverages Candles

Cakes

Cakes

Valrhona Chocolate Cake Slice

Valrhona Chocolate Cake with chocolate mocha cream cheese icing.
$11.50

Red Velvet Cake Slice

Red Velvet Cake with Cream Cheese Icing
$11.50

Carrot Cake Slice

Betty's famous carrot cake with cream cheese icing.
$11.50

Old Fashioned Apple Cake Slice
$8.00

Lemon Bundt Cake Slice
$7.50

Mini - Cheesecake
$9.00

Old Fashioned Nectarine Cake
$6.25

Steak & Cheese Pie (4.5 inch hand pie)

If you love meat and cheese, this is the pie for you. Braised, all natural short rib seasoned with rosemary, thyme, and caramelized onions in a mouth-watering gravy and topped with white cheddar cheese.
$12.50

Shepherd's Pie (4.5 inch hand held pie)

Whether you call it a Shepherd's Pie or a Cottage Pie, our version of this classic pie has quickly become a cult classic. Made with lean ground beef, sweet corn, carrots, peas, and caramelized onions in a savory tomato sauce and topped with herbed mashed potato.
$13.00

Brazilian Chicken Pie (4.5 inch hand held pie)

Tender pieces of all natural chicken in a Cuban inspired sofrito, with fresh peas, carrots, and coconut milk. Enjoy!
$11.50

Thai Chicken Pie (4.5 inch hand held pie)

For people who like a little spice. Tender pieces of all natural chicken, mushrooms, peas, carrots, ginger & lemon grass in a slightly spicy coconut milk and red Thai curry sauce.
$11.50

Curry Vegetable Pie (4.5 inch hand held pie)

There is no better way to get your vegetables than in a pie! Cauliflower florets, fresh peas, crispy broccoli, succulent mushrooms, crunchy carrots, buttery squash, and potatoes in a rich, aromatic Indian curry.
$9.50

Argentine Empanada Pie (4.5 inch hand held pie)

This savory pie is filled with ground beef, red and green peppers, green olives, and Argentine spices.
$11.50

Spinach Egg & Cheese Pie (4.5 inch hand held pie)

A whole egg, garlic, and spinach, with feta, ricotta, and mozzarella cheeses.
$8.00

Moroccan Breakfast Pie (4.5 inch hand held pie)

Perfect for people looking for a quality breakfast option. Whole egg baked in a house-made shashuka (garlic, jalapeno, onions, red pepper, tomato, and spices).
$8.00

Bacon Egg and Cheese Pie (4.5 inch hand held pie)

Bacon Egg & Cheese Breakfast Pie: Breakfast pies are the perfect for people wanting quality breakfast options. Smoked farm house bacon, free range egg and aged white cheddar cheese.
$8.00

Savory Pies

Savory Pies

Cookies

Cookies

Small Cookies by the Pound

A party pleaser! Note that one pound of cookies gives you approximately 30-40 pieces.
$10.00

The Curly Brunette

Packed with coconut, oats, pecans and chocolate chunks.
$5.00

The Waldo

The ultimate walnut chocolate chip cookie
$6.00

Chocolate Chip
$5.00

Oatmeal Raisin
$5.00

Red Velvet Cookie

With white chocolate chunks
$5.00

Anzac

Eggless - Coconut and Oats
$3.25

Molasses
$5.00

Palmiers
$3.25

Classic Ring Ding

Chocolate cake filled with vanilla buttercream and dipped in chocolate.
$7.00

Nutella Ring Ding

Chocolate cake filled with Nutella and Nutella buttercream, dipped in chocolate with a hazelnut on top!
$5.25

Twinkie

House made version of the classic we grew up with.
$5.00

Rice Krispy Treats

Brown Butter Rice Krispy Treats.
$5.50

Retro Items

Retro Items

Sweet Pies

Sweet Pies

Blueberry Pie
$5.50

Pecan Pie
$5.50

Dutch Apple Pie (4.5 inches)

The classic apple pie taken to a new level. Using locally grown apples sourced from the Hudson Valley our Apple Pie is a chorus of vanilla, brown butter and spices, topped with our famous buttery & crunchy brown butter streusel.
$9.00

Pumpkin Pie
$5.50

Strawberry Rhubarb Pie (Slice)
$5.25

Rustic Pie

French style rustic pies filled with seasonal fruit. Currently plums.
$6.50

Traditional Apple Pie (4.5 inches)

The classic apple pie taken to a new level. Using locally grown apples sourced from the Hudson Valley our Apple Pie is a chorus of vanilla, brown butter and spices piled high in our famous, flaky crust.
$9.00

Blueberry Pie (4.5 inches)

Nothing beats our Blueberry Pie! Ripe, luscious blueberries mixed with a proprietary blend of butter and spices, baked in our flaky pastry. A year round classic.
$7.50

Blondie

Brown sugar and butterscotch blondie.
$5.50

Lemon Coconut Bar
$5.50

Pecan Bar

Like a portable pecan pie with a layer of chocolate.
$4.25

Walnut Brownie
$5.50

Brownie
$5.50

Bars and Pops

Bars and Pops

Tarts

Tarts

Chocolate Caramel Tart

Caramel, chocolate ganache, cocoa nibs and sea salt in a tart crust.
$7.50

Lemon Curd Tart

Betty's take on the classic French lemon tart.
$7.50

Cupcake
$3.50

Vanilla Vanilla Cupcake
$5.50

Vanilla Chocolate Cupcake
$5.50

Vanilla Strawberry Cupcake
$5.50

Chocolate Chocolate Cupcake
$5.50

Chocolate Vanilla Cupcake
$5.50

Chocolate Strawberry Cupcake
$5.50

Chocolate Coconut Cupcake
$3.95

Red Velvet Cupcake

Red Velvet Cake with Cream Cheese Icing
$5.50

Carrot Cake Cupcake
$5.50

Cupcakes

Cupcakes

Beverages

Beverages

Bottled Water (1/2 liter)
$4.00

Strawberry Lemonade
$3.99

Mint Lemonade
$3.99

Hot Coffee
$2.50

Hot Chocolate
$4.75

Chai Latte
$4.25

Small Latte (12 oz)
$3.75

Sparkler
$7.00

Candles

Candles